"The Darkest Of Nights"
Listenability - 9/10 - The Drums and synths at the beginning are actually quite nice, and work together well. The bass is a nice touch too Even though, at first glance, it appears to be 'just another song', it actually pulls it off in a way that isn't bad for the song It's got a spiffy-fun tune and good strength ^^
Replayabiltiy - 10/10 - Must...Download...Song...
Danceability - 9/10 - Groovalicous ^^
Genre Matching - 8/10 - It almost seems more techno than ambient, but it does carry those ambient traits
Reliability - 9/10 - It keeps up a good strength and a good rythm throughout ^_^
Overall: - 8.9/10 - Very spiffy fun ^_^ It almost comes off as a game soundtrack too ^^ It's got a lot of stuff going for it
The arrangement is very professional, and the instrumental loops are provided just long enough to give a hypnotic feel. Nothing is overdone in the piece – everything is repeated in a subtle and indistinct fashion. Another thing I must praise is the production quality. This bad boy is ready for the radio, and would sound great in a car or home theater system.
The only thing that I have to criticize comes at the very end of the track. At the three minute mark, the track appears to end. Nothing wrong here – but for some reason the drum beat begins again a few seconds later. I have heard this type of “fake” ending for hip hop works, but it really doesn’t work for an all-instrumental new age track. The lack of vocals make it unnecessary to “break it down,” and it can only invite people to copy and loop something I’m sure Smith worked hard on.
So there you have it – “Under the Night Sky” is sure to please anyone looking for a relaxing piece with style. As a matter of fact, it might even please fans of instrumental hip hop due to it’s crisp bass and smooth rhythm.
-Justin Hess
In fairness to Mr. Smith, the piece is fairly well done .and is of some interest. He has good production values. I did find that the overuse of some patterns and sounds makes this more akin to an incidental music track in a video game. You know this type of track that I’m talking about… While wandering though an adventure game, you work your way up and down streets and alleys, going in and out of buildings, and all the while the repetitive background music makes you feel it’s presence without ever being distracting. This is that kind of number.
I get the feeling that this piece was rather experimental on Anthony’s part. Even though I have reviewed another of his numbers, I took the time to again listen to some of the other music on his site. Quite a bit of it is rather innovative. This piece allows it’s theme to get a much too repetitious, and could do with some light counter melody to balance out its cyclical nature. This track could use a little more depth in the instrumentation, but overall, it is a simple, nicely understated number.
Bill Wright
When I say "almost flawlessly", I'm referring to the synthesization of the Native flute and drum in this song. Done traditionally, the flute often has an imprecise intonation that is hard for the western ear to digest, and the drum relies more on tonality than it does on rhythmic perfection. Smith has smoothed these idiosyncrasies out, making "almost flawlessly" into a distinct advantage, and a service to Natives that traditionalists, sadly, will reject and misunderstand until the day they drop.
"Forgotten War" sacrifices nothing in authenticity; the truncated scale of Native flute, the tonal drop-offs at the end of phrases, and distinct timbre of the instrument are all here. The melody is haunting, and the synth drums actually seem to amplify sacred intent. The dynamics are impressive... the silences speak volumes! This beautiful tune does not appropriate Native culture; it honors it with the respect it deserves, and that is a bridge built that few who attempt this genre actually achieve. This should appeal to less traditional NDNs (who have NOT forgotten) and New Agers alike; I'm adding it to my permanent collection. Kudos, Mr. Smith!
~~~~tod~~~~